Every Restaurant Space Around Watertown Square This Fall Already Has a Next Tenant

At 58 Mt. Auburn St., a sign on the old Home Taste door says the space will be closed for about a month and that the restaurant is changing direction. Farther down the street at 39 Mt. Auburn St., the room where Halva Mediterranean Grill served kebabs for almost three years is empty. On Arsenal Street, the burger counter that fed the neighborhood for 22 years served its last meal on Sept. 25.

In every case the next operator was announced before the old one finished closing, and most of the newcomers are established local restaurants that are expanding, not first-time operators trying their luck.

The handoffs, address by address

Address What closed What's next Status as last reported
39 Mt. Auburn St. Halva Mediterranean Grill, which moved A breakfast spot from Halva's owners No name or date announced as of Aug. 21
55 Main St. Not Your Average Joe's Halva Mediterranean Grill Open since Aug. 19
58 Mt. Auburn St. Home Taste Badam Uyghur Cuisine Opening listed as November, per Oct. 2 report
46 Arsenal St. Belle's Burgers & Ice Cream Buff's Burgers & Wings Waiting on a beer and wine license transfer, per Sept. 17 report
212 Waverley Ave. Pizza Roma Bougie Pizza Co. Moved in, per Sept. 21 report

Reading the table top to bottom, one move sets off the next. Halva's growth emptied a Mt. Auburn Street room, and Halva's owners already have a plan for it. Belle's closing opened up an Arsenal Street space, and a Newton Corner institution quickly claimed it. None of these addresses was put up for anyone to take.

Halva started it by outgrowing Mt. Auburn Street

Watertown News reported that Halva Mediterranean Grill opened on Wednesday, Aug. 19, in the former Not Your Average Joe's at 55 Main St. Co-owner Joseph Dagdelen told the paper the new room is about four times the size of the Mt. Auburn Street space, which was once home to the New Yorker Diner.

That size difference explains the move. Halva didn't leave Watertown Square. It moved to a bigger spot on another side of it, and the owners kept the old lease. Watertown News reported that 39 Mt. Auburn St. is set to become a breakfast restaurant serving American food with Mediterranean touches, from the same team. No name, hours or opening date had been announced as of that August report, so for now the old room is a planned breakfast spot.

The Square came out ahead on both counts. A dinner spot got four times the seating, and a morning spot is planned for the room it left behind.

On the same street, a Cambridge restaurateur takes over Home Taste

Home Taste at 58 Mt. Auburn St. closed in September, and WhatNow Boston reported on Sept. 18 that Adila Sadir is taking over the space for Badam Uyghur Cuisine. Sadir founded Silk Road in Cambridge, which Watertown News described as the Boston area's first Uyghur restaurant.

Boston.com's Oct. 2 roundup of new openings lists Badam's opening as November and gives the best preview of the menu: hand-pulled noodles, lamb kebabs and rice pilaf. The room seats about 16 people, and like Silk Road, it is expected to do a lot of quick takeout. WhatNow reported proposed hours of 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily. Those are proposed hours, not a posted schedule. In the same piece, Sadir said she plans to start with a smaller menu so the cooking stays authentic and the service holds up, and that she hopes to introduce people to Uyghur culture as well as the food.

With 16 seats and a takeout focus, Badam fits a Mt. Auburn Street storefront well. Once it and the planned breakfast spot open, this short stretch of Mt. Auburn will have changed over completely in one season, with no vacant period worth mentioning between tenants.

Arsenal Street gets a wing bar with 98 seats

Belle's Burgers & Ice Cream at 46 Arsenal St. closed Friday, Sept. 25. The same owners ran Wild Willy's Burgers in that spot before Belle's. Their farewell letter, which Watertown News reprinted, read in part:

For more than two decades, we have had the privilege of serving our community, meeting so many wonderful people, and becoming a small part of countless family meals, celebrations, and memories.

The next tenant is another long-running local name. WhatNow Boston reported on Sept. 17 that Buff's Pub, which Don Fabrizio founded in Newton Corner in 1976, is expanding into the space as Buff's Burgers & Wings. The original Buff's is on Washington Street near the Newton-Watertown line, a short distance from the new site, which WhatNow described as just outside Watertown Square.

City permits cited in that report give the scale: 3,914 square feet, seating for up to 98 people, and listed hours of 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. daily. An electrical contractor working on the project mentioned plans for a "massive TV wall." The permits projected Oct. 19 for finishing the conversion. That date has now passed, but WhatNow said the opening still depends on transferring the beer and wine license, and second-generation owner Wes Fabrizio said he would share a timeline once that transfer is done. The menu goes beyond wings, with burgers, tenders, sandwiches, salads, burritos and bowls.

The pattern holds on Waverley Avenue and breaks at Arsenal Yards

The handoff pattern also holds farther from the Square. At 212 Waverley Ave., Pizza Roma closed and Bougie Pizza Co. moved in, with a menu of sourdough pizza and sandwiches. Watertown News listed its hours as Tuesday through Saturday, 4 to 9 p.m. In a Sept. 9 report, WhatNow Boston said owner David Bourgeois had confirmed the concept but hadn't shared opening plans. Bougie's own site is the best place to check before you go.

The one closing this fall that doesn't fit the pattern happened at Arsenal Yards. NBC Boston reported on Oct. 2 that Chip City had stopped operating across its chain, including the Arsenal Yards shop. That closing came from a decision made for a whole chain, not from anything happening on Arsenal Street, and no successor had been reported. It's the only empty food space on this list without a named next tenant, and it's also the only one that belonged to a chain.

Halloween weekend, starting the day after this post

The new places are still a few weeks out at best. Meanwhile, the city has two free Halloween events on back-to-back days this week.

  1. Halloween Happening, Friday, Oct. 23, 9:30 a.m., at Brigham House, 341 Mt. Auburn St. This free event for young children has music, puppets, crafts and trick-or-treating. Space is limited and an RSVP is required, according to Watertown News.
  2. Wicked Watertown, Saturday, Oct. 24, 4 to 7 p.m., at the Commander's Mansion, 440 Talcott Ave. The free activities include kids' games from the Watertown Recreation Department, ghost stories by flashlight from the Watertown Free Public Library, a costume contest with prizes, a photo booth from Natalie Nigito Photography, and a dance party with a performance by the BOSwitches. Icing on the Cake bakery will sell cupcakes on site, including gluten-free options.
  3. The haunted house is the one ticketed part. Advance tickets are $5 per person until noon on Friday, Oct. 23, and children under three get in free. At the door the price goes up to $10 per person, cash only, according to the city's announcement as published by Watertown News.

For Saturday's haunted house, the deadline to watch is noon Friday, when advance tickets stop selling.

The library running Saturday's ghost stories is partway through a lobby redesign. Watertown News published the library's announcement, which said the Watertown Free Public Library would close Oct. 13 for desk renovation as the first step of a multi-stage project. A smaller circulation desk is meant to make room for open holds, so patrons can pick up held items from the shelf without waiting in line. Self-checkout through the Minuteman Mobile app and a first-floor display of new materials are also coming. On Mt. Auburn Street, the city scheduled sidewalk, curb and drainage work in mid-October, and its notice said one lane in each direction would stay open. That schedule was short-term and depended on the weather, so check the city's latest notice before driving the corridor.

What to watch for next

Two things will show where the Square is headed this winter. One is Badam's opening, now listed for November. The other is the license transfer that lets Buff's Burgers & Wings open on Arsenal Street. After those comes the name of the breakfast spot planned for 39 Mt. Auburn St., the room that started this chain of moves when Halva needed four times the space.

If you're watching Watertown Square change and wondering what it means for a home nearby, Nick Mescia follows these blocks address by address and is happy to talk it through over coffee, or over breakfast once that new spot on Mt. Auburn opens. Let's Connect.

Work With Nick

Get assistance in determining the current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Let him guide you through your home buying journey, contact him today!

Let's Connect